People Know Something Is Wrong. They Just Can’t Quite Name It.

Something is happening across Europe.

The immediate causes differ from country to country, but similar frustrations keep appearing around them: the cost of living, housing, deteriorating public services and a broader sense that living standards are moving backwards. France has just experienced some of its worst unrest in years, while Italy has seen demonstrations of its own. The local triggers are different, but some of the underlying economic grievances are familiar.

It would be easy to treat this purely as politics, but I think there is something deeper going on.

For most of my life there has been an unspoken social contract in developed economies: get an education, find a good job, work hard, and you should eventually be able to buy a home and afford to raise a family. It was never a promise that everyone would become wealthy. It was much more basic than that. If you did the things society asked of you, the normal milestones of adulthood should remain within reach.

Increasingly, that promise does not seem to hold. You can get the degree, build the career, earn a good income and do everything you were told to do, yet still find yourself unable to afford the house your parents could buy on much more ordinary incomes, or wondering whether you can actually afford to have the family you expected to have.

People may not understand precisely why that has happened, but they can still feel that something is wrong.

The Boat I Can Fix But Don’t Want to Replace

I’ve been thinking about this recently while rebuilding my old fishing boat.

I’ve owned it for years and recently started repairing and redesigning parts of it, fixing cracks, changing load paths, fabricating components, rewiring it, painting it and spending a ridiculous amount of time thinking about how everything should go together. I’ve actually found it enormously satisfying because there is something tangible about finding a physical problem, understanding why it failed and building a better solution.

But there is another reason I’m rebuilding it. I’d quite like to buy a new boat, then I look at what they cost.

My income has increased considerably since I bought the old one, yet the replacement cost has somehow kept moving away from me as well. A boat is ultimately a collection of aluminium or fibreglass, an engine, electronics, freight and skilled labour, and nearly all of those inputs have become materially more expensive.

So I repair what I already have.

That is hardly a living-standard crisis. Nobody needs a new fishing boat. But a house is different, and when the same process begins affecting shelter, the consequences are much more important.

What Happens When the Money Gets Bigger but the Board Doesn’t?

The easiest way I know to explain part of this is Monopoly.

Imagine playing a game where every time somebody goes around the board, more money is added to the game. Everyone gradually has more dollars, but there are still only four railways, one Boardwalk and one Park Place. If players are allowed to bid against each other for those assets, progressively increasing the amount of money in circulation does not create any more scarce squares. It simply gives people more money with which to compete for the ones that already exist.

Eventually, ownership of the board becomes more important than how much somebody receives when they pass Go.

The real economy is obviously much more complicated. We build more houses, businesses create productive assets, technology increases output, population changes, credit conditions change and governments tax, spend and redistribute income. Money and credit also do not translate mechanically into asset prices.

But over long periods, the stock of money and credit can expand much faster than the supply of genuinely scarce assets, particularly well-located land. That is the form of monetary debasement that matters most to households: claims on scarce assets can grow much faster than the number of desirable assets available to own. Credit makes that mechanism more powerful.

The rate of monetary growth is not constant either. Euro-area broad money is currently growing at around 3.5% a year, considerably slower than during some previous periods. The point is not what happens in any single year, but what decades of compounding do to the relationship between money, credit and things whose supply cannot expand nearly as quickly.

Australia provides a useful historical example. RBA research found that financial deregulation and falling nominal interest rates substantially increased household borrowing capacity from the late 1980s onwards. Households could borrow more against the same income, and some of that additional spending capacity was capitalised into higher dwelling prices.

Nobody needed to set out to make housing less accessible. It emerged from the system.

The Difference Between Earning Money and Owning Things

This helps explain something conventional measures of living standards do not always capture very well.

A household can regain its ability to buy roughly the same basket of everyday goods while simultaneously becoming less able to acquire a scarce asset. Those are two different forms of purchasing power. Housing shows the distinction clearly. EU house prices are still rising, up 4.7% over the year to the June quarter of 2026, and over the decade since 2015 they have risen 63.6% against 21.1% for rents. Australia has experienced the same broad structural shift over a much longer period, as rising borrowing capacity and constrained supply in desirable locations allowed housing prices to move much faster than incomes for long stretches of time.

Once that happens, there is an important difference between somebody whose financial position comes primarily from earning income and somebody who already owns assets. Suppose wages grow at 3% while a scarce asset grows at 6%. The difference barely seems important after one year, but compound it for twenty years and the two people end up in very different financial positions.

The person who already owned the asset participated in the repricing. The person trying to save enough from wages to acquire it has been chasing a moving target.

Over time, what was supposed to be a reward for working can increasingly become a reward for having arrived earlier.

That is how a society can become wealthier in aggregate while a large number of people feel as though they are moving backwards. GDP, wages and household wealth can all rise, but if an increasing share of that wealth is represented by assets that are becoming harder for non-owners to acquire, the lived experience of that economy changes.

It may also help explain part of the decline in birthrates across developed economies.

If the social contract was that education and hard work should eventually allow you to buy a home and raise a family, then housing becoming progressively less attainable changes more than the property market. Children require space, time and financial security, and for many households having another child eventually means needing another bedroom, a larger home or moving somewhere more suitable.

Expensive housing is clearly not the only reason fertility rates are falling. Education, women’s participation in the labour force, contraception, childcare, employment security, changing social expectations and the difficulty of balancing work and family all matter. But housing is part of the equation. Across the OECD, the average fertility rate has fallen from 3.3 children per woman in 1960 to around 1.5 in 2022, well below the replacement rate of roughly 2.1, and people are also having children later. OECD research has found a negative relationship between rising housing expenditure and fertility.

That matters because delaying a family is not necessarily the same as having the same family later. Biology imposes a time constraint that housing markets do not. If it takes longer to finish education, establish a career, build a deposit and acquire suitable housing, the age at which people feel secure enough to start a family moves later as well. Some will still have the number of children they intended to have, while others will have fewer.

Seen in that light, the breakdown in the social contract becomes more consequential. People have done what they were told to do, yet some of the outcomes that work and education were supposed to make possible keep moving further away.

Australia May Be Reaching Its Affordability Limit

I think Australia is entering a particularly interesting phase of this process, and the current housing downturn is already showing where the constraint sits.

Higher-value homes have been leading the falls in Sydney and Melbourne, while units and lower-priced housing have generally proved more resilient. Regional markets have held up better than the capitals as well, with regional dwelling values down 1.9% over the September quarter against a 4.3% decline across the combined capitals. These are not necessarily separate phenomena. They can all be understood through the same constraint: buyers are being pushed down the affordability curve.

If the detached house is no longer affordable, they buy the unit. If the inner or middle-ring suburb no longer works, they move further out. If the capital city no longer works, some move towards regional markets.

At some point that stops being merely a cyclical response to expensive housing and becomes a structural change in what Australians regard as normal housing. We may be approaching that point.

The detached house has historically been the default Australian aspiration, with medium and high-density housing often treated as the compromise. But density solves one problem monetary policy cannot: it divides the cost of expensive land among more households.

If land keeps becoming more valuable relative to household income, the economics progressively favour putting more dwellings on it. That shift is already visible in approvals, with Australia approving 48,778 apartments in 2025-26, 13.2% more than the previous financial year.

It does not mean detached housing disappears. It means the marginal buyer increasingly gets pushed towards smaller dwellings, greater density or cheaper locations.

The housing system is adapting to the affordability ceiling.

The Long Cycle Is Starting to Collide With the Housing Cycle

This is where I think it becomes particularly interesting for property.

I’ve spent a lot of time looking at roughly sixty years of Australian housing-market data, and one pattern I keep coming back to is that the cycles appear to be compressing.

Housing has always been cyclical. Credit becomes easier, purchasing power improves and prices rise. Eventually affordability deteriorates, demand weakens and the market slows or corrects, before prices or incomes gradually repair the imbalance and the process begins again.

But imagine each new cycle beginning from a progressively higher price-to-income base. There is less runway.

A market that starts with houses costing three or four times household income can absorb a substantial increase in prices before borrowing capacity becomes the binding constraint. A market already sitting close to its affordability limit cannot. Credit conditions improve, prices respond, borrowing capacity gets consumed more quickly and the market runs back into the ceiling sooner, and the cycle has less room to breathe.

That may be part of what we are seeing now. Higher-value housing has reacted more sharply to tighter credit, while cheaper dwellings have proved more resilient. Units are outperforming houses in many markets and regional markets have generally held up better than capitals. Those patterns make sense if affordability is becoming increasingly important in determining where the next dollar of housing demand can go.

The long monetary and credit cycle keeps increasing the nominal value of scarce assets over decades, while the shorter property cycle repeatedly runs into the household’s ability to finance those values. Those two forces are beginning to collide.

If that interpretation is right, the Australian housing market of the future may look different from the one many people became accustomed to. Cycles may become shorter, changes in momentum sharper, and performance increasingly dispersed between parts of the market that remain affordable and those that have already reached their borrowing-capacity ceiling.

Units can outperform houses, regional markets can outperform capitals and lower-priced suburbs can outperform premium ones. Then conditions change and capital moves again.

The national average becomes progressively less useful because the constraint is increasingly specific to the household and the market it is trying to enter.

For the Individual, the Durable Response Is Ownership

That leaves an uncomfortable question. If wages alone are struggling to keep pace with the assets that ultimately determine financial security, what can an individual actually do about it?

You cannot control monetary policy, land scarcity, planning systems, population growth or what somebody else is willing to pay for a house. But where circumstances allow it, you can change how exposed you are to the same forces.

If productive and scarce assets tend to reprice over time while cash and wages do not necessarily keep pace, then one rational response is to gradually convert part of the income generated by work into ownership.

That does not mean buying property at any price, nor does it mean putting every spare dollar into one asset class. It means recognising that income and wealth are different things, and that a household relying entirely on labour income occupies a very different position from one that gradually accumulates assets.

For someone trying to build wealth, that suggests a different way of thinking about income: not only as something to spend, but as something that can progressively be converted into ownership. Property is one route, equities are another, superannuation already does this automatically for most Australians, and businesses and other productive assets can do it as well.

The particular asset matters, as do price, risk and diversification. But if the assets you eventually want to own are compounding faster than your income, saving cash indefinitely and hoping wages eventually catch up becomes a difficult race to win. For households that have the capacity to do it, having at least part of their capital exposed to productive or scarce assets changes that relationship.

That is one reason wealthier households tend to have much greater exposure to assets than households relying primarily on wages. They are not dependent solely on increases in the price of their labour. Part of the income produced by that labour has been converted into things that can appreciate, produce income or both.

It does not solve inequality and it does not fix the housing problem for society. At an individual level, however, it changes how the same economic forces affect you. Asset inflation is no longer purely something happening to the things you hope to buy. Some of it is also reflected in things you already own.

Perhaps that is the most important investment implication hidden beneath some of the anger we are seeing in Europe. People do not need to understand monetary aggregates, credit creation or discount rates to know when something feels wrong. They know how many years of their life a house costs, what their rent costs, what replacing a car costs and whether raising a family feels easier or harder than it did for the generation before them.

The statistics can tell people that inflation is falling, wages are rising and the economy is growing, and all of those things may be true. But people are measuring their living standards against something else: whether an education, a decent job and years of hard work can still provide a home, a family and a reasonable degree of security.

Increasingly, the economic statistics and that lived measure of progress are giving very different answers.

That may be the part of the social contract that is starting to break.


3rd Nov
The Market Is Not the Economy
27th Oct
Short-Term and Long-Term Rental in Australia: The Basics
Illustration of common property investment myths being busted
13th Oct
The Property Investment Myths We Swear Are True
There are no results to display. Please try a different keyword or reset the filters to see everything.

Subscribe for free property investment advice, resources & education

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.